As an NYC resident, I'm constantly passing by stylish neighbors in various boroughs. Whether I'm frolicking in Fort Greene and Bed-Stuy or heading downtown to the Lower East Side, I've taken note of recurring trends in each neighborhood—particularly heel trends. The shoes you wear say so much about you, and as I pass by fashionable women on my daily strolls, their heels tell me they are fabulous. The heel trends they're wearing aren't necessarily new, but they are eye-catching. From classic pointed-toe pumps to simple slingback kitten heels, these New Yorkers know how to make a statement.
Each outfit they wear has an element of chicness that I attribute to one of these heel trends. Think of simple jeans elevated by a pair of pumps or a lace-trim skirt paired with peep-toe heels for a casual yet chic vibe. These are the outfits I've been seeing, so keep scrolling to shop each trend and enhance your daily looks.
Classic Pointed-Toe Pumps
Classic pointed-toe pumps will never go out of style. They are just the best shoes to make an outfit look much more polished and put-together. Whether you're wearing a pair of jeans or a simple skirt, pointed-toe pumps are always dependable for elevating your outfits. I'm not one to wear this trend often, but whenever I see someone stomping through the streets of NYC with confidence in a pair of pointed-toe pumps, I can't help but want to wear a pair too.
Shop Classic Pointed-Toe Heels
Peep-Toe Heels
Peep-toe heels had a big moment last year, with influencers wearing them with straight-leg jeans. The spring/summer 2025 runway collections, from Tory Burch to Prada, featured the trend, and now, it's back and better than ever. Fashion lovers are wearing them with skirts more often than not, and I am loving it. This trend makes an outfit look fun and flirty. If that's what you're going for, I highly recommend wearing a pair. I've also seen city girls wearing them with long shorts and capri pants. They're much more versatile shoes than you'd think.
Shop Peep-Toe Heels
Square-Toe Heels
I forgot about square-toe block heels until I saw a friend of mine wearing a pair out and about. What I love about the city is the feeling of serendipity it always has. It's as if I were meant to run into her so I could be reminded of how fun a shoe trend can be. I used to wear this style as a child for special occasions, and now, it's back and worn by the coolest girls I know. Square-toe block heels look phenomenal with a dress or skirt outfit, and they're perfect for long wear, as the block heel offers much more support than a stiletto would.
Shop Square-Toe Block Heels
Slingback Kitten Heels
Every stylish dresser in the city knows they have to have a comfortable and chic pair of shoes to wear throughout the day. The one style I've seen people walk a ton of blocks in and still look put-together is slingback kitten heels. Similar to block heels, they're dependable shoes that won't ruin your feet after hours of wear. They make even a simple skirt or spring-friendly shorts look way more polished and less casual. They're easy shoes to be playful with and style in various ways, which is why they're the perfect shoes to wear around NYC.
Shop Kitten Heels
Animal-Print Heels
Animal print has been all the craze for multiple seasons now. I've seen animal-print bags, coats, and—of course—shoes. Animal-print heels have been everywhere I turn, IRL and online. From snakeskin to zebra to cheetah print, they're all chic and all over the city. They are the pop that a lot of simple outfits need. I've seen them styled with a plain white tee and jeans for a laid-back daytime look and with a skirt and jacket like this outfit. No matter the print, the trend is here to stay, and NYC outfits are the proof.
Shop Animal-Print Heels
T-Strap Heels
T-strap heels have been slowly but surely taking over the NYC fashion scene. I've been spotting fashion people wearing them with a simple pair of pants—even khakis, like the look below. They are the perfect addition to a spring outfit. I find them to be so chic and versatile, and I've even seen New Yorkers sporting the trend with skirt-and-tank-top outfits. This is one of those trends that makes you do a double take.
Shop T-Strap Heels
Two-Tone Heels
Thanks to Chanel, the arbiter of this trend, two-tone heels are everywhere. Ever since Chanel's S/S 26 ready-to-wear show, all the most stylish people in the city have been wearing two-tone heels. I know people who went to the Chanel store as soon as that collection was available for purchase. The shoes are indeed stunning. I've seen two-tone flats around the city since last year, but there's something in the air. Everyone has switched to heels, and I've been enjoying every minute of it. Cool dressers have been styling them with lightly layered outfits like the look below or going fully casual with a pair of jeans and a tank top. The options with two-tone heels are endless.
Shop Two-Tone Heels
Why Trust Us
At Who What Wear, fashion is our speciality. Our editors have years of industry experience, from reporting on seasonal fashion trends seen at international fashion weeks to working with some of the most recognizable names in fashion. Every item we recommend is carefully selected based on current trends, quality, and real-world wearability.
We regularly try pieces ourselves, including everything from best-selling jeans to designer shoes; speak to external experts and fashion insiders; and stay closely connected to what our readers are searching for. Our advice is grounded in expertise and has to pass our exceptional taste levels, so you can feel confident in every recommendation.