Understated, Intentional, Timeless: Your Fashion Guide to Fine Jewelry for Beginners

If there's one takeaway from the 2026 awards season, it's that jewelry is back—picture Elle Fanning in a vintage Cartier necklace at the Oscars or Teyana Taylor wearing Tiffany & Co. to the Golden Globes, which only means it’s a short time before the diamond-and-gemstone love jumps from the red carpet to our jewelry boxes. Speaking of which, mine feels bare compared to the finishings and settings of Hollywood’s most glamorous events. What did I expect, really? I’m young in life. A true fine jewelry collection takes years to curate.

While a common first introduction to fine jewelry is through an engagement ring. It’s safe to say that’s not happening anytime soon (speaking for myself, of course). But who’s to say fine jewelry can’t celebrate other milestones? A graduation, friendship, a scholarship, motherhood, a first job, or just because. Yes, jewelry is an investment, but it is also a companion that endures for generations. There, that’s solved. Now, on to my next question: how does one start a fine jewelry collection? With hopes of an overwhelmingly chic jewelry box one day, I asked six chic, beginner-friendly fine jewelry brands the same question. I invite you to scroll on to read their advice.

How to Build a Fine Jewelry Collection

Versatile pieces build the foundation of a fine jewelry collection. A simple tennis bracelet. Basic diamond studs. Classic gold hoops. An elegant pendant. Vintage pinky rings. Stacked bands. A comfortable chain. These are the beginnings of a lifelong collection. The best tennis bracelets, the best diamond studs, the best bands all have one thing in common. They are designed to be seen and worn, not safely stowed in a box.

Heirloom-worthy jewelry collections are not built overnight, but piece by piece, so that one day, your collection acts as “a symbol of love, memory, and life’s defining moments,” or at least that’s how Sophie Bille Brahe described hers. Across the six different brands, each has its own recommendations for a first-time jewelry buyer, but the consensus is to start with the basics and make sure it's something you'll actually wear.

Lab-Grown Vs. Natural Diamonds

During my talks with brand founders and jewelry designers, the lab-grown-versus-natural-diamond discussion was inevitable. Still, as with any investment, it is important to ask the hard-hitting questions. The fine jewelry industry, like office jargon, has its own vocabulary. If unfamiliar with the lingo, questions such as these can feel intimidating. Steph Mazuera, an NYC-based fine jewelry designer, was as eager to answer my questions as I was to ask them. Given all its complexities, Mazuera shared the following: “I work with both lab and natural, often using lab diamonds for their accessibility and impact, especially in pieces like studs and tennis bracelets. That said, natural diamonds have an undeniable individuality, and when I source them, I’m especially drawn to antique stones or those with unique, unconventional character.”

In fact, some brands deal only in natural diamonds. Take Aaryah, for example, founder Megan Kothari, who works only with natural stones, shared, “There is an energy to them that you can actually feel.” Alternatively, Dorsey, an online-only brand that works exclusively with lab-grown stones, highlights the extensive range of lab-grown diamonds and sapphires available across a variety of aesthetics and price points.

The Best Brands to Start a Jewelry Collection

Ahead is an editor-curated list of the best brands for a fine jewelry collection. A few have been around for many years, while others are buzzy and new. This list covers everything from natural stones to lab-grown pieces, nods to heritage and modern retellings, and of course, the pieces central to building a lasting and versatile collection.

Sophie Bille Brahe

“Jewellery should hold emotion—a quiet reflection of who you are and the life you’re living,” said Brahe. Her eponymous brand takes inspiration from her Scandinavian roots and her poetic nature, which became clearer to me the more I learned of her beginnings.

One of the first things Brahe shared with me was a charming recollection of her childhood: “My earliest memory of jewellery is watching my father search all night for my mother’s lost Cartier watch along the waterfront in Hornbæk, Denmark. It held such meaning for her, and seeing the relief on her face when he found it made me understand, even as a child, how deeply jewellery can become part of someone’s life.” Brahe’s understanding of the relationship between a piece and its wearer is manifest in her work.

During my visit to the new NYC Boutique on Madison Avenue (a beautifully intimate and heavily curated space), I witnessed Brahe’s enigmatic whimsy. “My designs often begin with a feeling — something I sense but can’t yet describe,” said Brahe. The cascading pearls, architectural finishes, oceanic references, and sculptural diamonds are all conscious details designed to elicit emotion in the wearer. It only made sense when she told me how she spent her younger years encompassed by antiques and heirlooms, which she links to “[her] desire to create pieces that feel timeless."

Those who wear a Sophie Bille Brahe piece return because, as Brahe puts it, “they feel connected to the universe we’ve created. Each piece is designed to complement the next, so their collection becomes a personal narrative.” Brahe’s storytelling is evident throughout her work, from her Icon pieces, such as the Grande Ensemble Ocean ring, which she wears as a gift after the birth of her daughter, to her intricate pearlwork. For Brahe, purity and narrative are the emphasis: “How simply can you show a diamond, how clean can you show a pearl,” and how, “When you choose something that resonates deeply, it becomes a companion, something you carry through your days and perhaps pass on one day.”

Kinn Studio

Jewelry is personal. To Brahe, it is “emotional.” To a fiancé, it is a declaration of love (both to the giver and the receiver). To Kinn Studio, it is an heirloom. “For us, jewelry isn’t meant to sit in a box waiting for a special occasion. It becomes meaningful through wear—through the life that happens around it,” said Kinn’s founder Jennie Yoon. Born from loss, Yoon began the studio to recreate family heirlooms lost in a home robbery. Kinn’s beginnings touched me because, sadly, I share a similar story. My family originates from Cyprus, and much of my Yiaya’s collection has been stolen. Years and years of legacy stones and generations of metalwork lost. The pain arises not from a monetary loss but from the loss of tangible artifacts of family history.

Kinn’s dedication to designing modern heirlooms is not only inspiring, but also a solution for customers who want jewelry that feels heritaged. “A modern heirloom, through the lens of Kinn, is something that lives with you through different chapters of your life,” said Yoon. As my grandmother viewed her pieces, Yoon notes, “Fine jewelry collections are rarely built all at once.” Though “A necklace is usually the easiest place to start, especially a simple gold chain that you never have to take off,” recommends Yoon. She pointed out the Mia and Matisse Link Chains as beautiful beginner pieces. “I also love suggesting a small pair of gold hoops or huggies—they instantly elevate whatever you’re wearing,” shared Yoon—her recommendation: the Teardrop Hoop Earrings.

Kinn Studio recently celebrated the opening of a NYC flagship boutique. Located in the West Village, I stepped into the space and instantly felt as if I had opened my grandmother’s jewelry box. If you find yourself on Bleeker Street, I suggest you pop in. Both Yoon and her sales staff are well educated on the fine jewelry space. I look to Yoon to weigh in on the lab-versus-natural discussion. Yoon answered with great nuance: “We offer both lab and natural diamonds at Kinn, and the right choice really comes down to what matters most to the client. Some people are drawn to the rarity and tradition of natural diamonds, while others prioritize size or budget, where lab diamonds can offer incredible value.”

Steph Mazuera

My introduction to Steph Mazuera was through Who What Wear associate features editor Ana Escalante. Here’s Esclante on her bespoke engagement ring from the designer: “I first discovered Mazuera through TikTok, and after she randomly messaged me out of the blue one day, showing me a picture of a diamond she saw she thought would be perfect for me, I was convinced. Mazuera ended up creating my engagement ring—a half-bezel bypass setting sculptured around a one-of-a-kind buttery yellow pear-shaped diamond. Over the last few months, I've collected a few of Mazuera's diamond basic pieces for everyday use since I've fallen so in love with her designs.”

I met with Mazuera in her Downtown, NYC office to discuss her new line of everyday diamond pieces: the Billie Tennis Bracelet, the Alpi Earring, the Arc Tennis Bracelet, and more. All of which are handcrafted in New York. Like Yoon, Mazuera encourages clients to start with the fundamentals. “I recommend starting with diamond studs or a classic tennis bracelet, pieces you can enjoy daily and use as the foundation for building an entire fine jewelry collection,” suggested Mazuera.

Then, we touched on the delicate topic of lab-grown versus natural diamonds. Asking her to be succinct was difficult, given all its complexities. A bonus of Mazuera's consultation is her kind, educational tone and extensive industry knowledge. “There’s an undeniable romance to natural diamonds, formed over billions of years, but not every purchase needs to carry that weight. Labgrown offers a more effortless way in while still being real and enduring, especially when sourced with the same level of care and quality as natural stones," shared Mazuera.

Dorsey

Dorsey deals only in lab-grown diamonds. I asked Meg Strachan, Dorsey’s founder, what is exclusive to the Dorsey buying experience. “We lead with design, not stone hierarchy, and [Dorsey sells] every lab stone from diamond to sapphire.” While, as she states, “Most heritage brands keep fine jewelry aesthetics behind high price points. [Dorsey offers] the same design across multiple stones and metals, allowing the customer to choose how they enter the space.”

“Fine jewelry is an investment in the materials, but it’s really up to the customer and their budget,” clarifies Strachan. “A first-time buyer can start with high-quality lab-grown moissanite for a few hundred dollars or can opt for 14K gold and lab-grown diamond pieces,” Stratched goes on to note, “These stones are molecularly identical to mined counterparts.” As a first-time buyer myself, I can appreciate Strachan’s clear presentation of Dorsey's approach to the lab-grown conversation.

You’ll see that family is a common theme when talking about jewelry. Dorsey is no different. Here is Strachan's advice to shoppers: “Buy pieces that you’ll actually reach for every day. I always build my outfit around my jewelry, which is something I learned from my grandmother, Dorsey. She believed jewelry shouldn't be saved for a special occasion, and you should look for pieces that feel like an extension of your personal style.” She followed up with foundational pieces from Doresy’s collection.

Aaryah

Aaryah is an investment in natural diamonds. I saw this firsthand in my visit to the NYC showroom. There, I met with Kothari. “I built Aaryah because the traditional jewelry experience often felt transactional, intimidating, and honestly very male-driven,” she shared. Her intention was to create a space that felt collaborative. “Everything we do is centered around the client, we do is centered around the client—how they want to shop, what they’re celebrating, how they want to feel. Whether it’s online or in our NYC showroom, each private shopping appointment is curated and deeply personal.”

At the showroom, I tried on the BB Thelma ring. It is a pinky ring that features a pear-cut stone (your choice of sapphire, gemstone, or natural diamond—I personally love the look of a yellow diamond) in a by-pass setting, available in 14KT yellow gold with a platform or satin finish. The pink ring is loved by the fashion set for its retro origins and modern silhouette. Tastemakers from Nara Smith to Aimee Song can be seen wearing it.

In addition to her recommendations for a first-time fine-jewelry buyer—pinky rings, stackable bands, a unique pendant, and a diamond hand chain—Kothari shared her views on natural diamonds. “We ethically source our diamonds from places like Canada, which have stricter labor laws than the US,” shared Kothari.

Blue Nile

“As the original online jeweler, Blue Nile was founded on the belief that exceptional quality should be accessible, transparent, and delivered directly to the customer,” said Katie Liappas, Blue Nile’s Chief Merchandising Officer.

Blue Nile’s appeal lies in its authenticity and educational nature. With over 25 years in the fine jewelry space, “Through its Diamond and Jewelry Education resources, customers gain clear, practical knowledge to empower confident purchasing decisions,” explained Liappas. Offering both lab-grown stone and natural diamonds, Liappas was proud to share, “All Blue Nile diamonds are conflict-free and comply with the Kimberley Process, ensuring responsible sourcing at every step.” For first-time buyers or those unfamiliar with the Kimperly Process, it is a global initiative that began in 2003 to eliminate conflict diamonds from the supply chain.

When asked how to begin a fine jewelry collection, Lippas said it's best to “start with the basics!” Her advice: “Invest in essentials that are timeless, versatile and designed to last - your ‘little black dress’ of jewelry. Diamond stud earrings or a classic tennis bracelet pair with any look - day or night be it your favorite jeans or an evening gown - and serve as the building blocks of a collection you can grow over time.” That seems to be the consensus among the experts and jewelry designers I’ve spoken with. A collection is ongoing, but, as with anything worth growing, the foundation is the most important step. Blue Nile is an approachable and accessible starting point.

Why Trust Us?

At Who What Wear, we know that beauty isn't one-size-fits-all. Over the years, our editors have tested thousands of products—including skincare, makeup, haircare, and nails—while also working closely with trusted experts, like renowned dermatologists, celebrity makeup artists, and other leading industry insiders. Together, this ensures every guide is well-researched, inclusive, and relevant to you.

We focus on formulas that deliver, whether they're affordable favorites or luxury investments. Our product selection is based on tangible results, ingredient know-how, and what we'd truly recommend to our closest friends and family members.