I've Finally Tired of Pink Nails—This Is the Chic Polish Shade I'm Wearing for the Foreseeable Future

Until a few months ago, a sheer pink or creamy off-white shade would have been my go-to for manicures year-round. For my last couple of trips to the nail salon, however, I've been flipping through the nail color display charts my technicians have given me and selecting toasty brown shades from my favorite polish brands. At first, I was tempted to play it safe—only selecting polish with light, neutral undertones. At some point, I finally tried a brown color that completely changed my mind.

Since then, cozy brown nails have become my go-to (and every at-home manicure I've done has looked better for it). Keep reading for expert-approved tips on how to select the best brown nail polish for your manicures. Then discover the 12 most elegant manicure ideas that I'll be wearing.

What Makes Brown Nails So Easy to Wear?

To learn more about brown manicures and why they're experiencing a a sudden boom in popularity just in time for the colder months, we tapped nail artist and educator Sofia Mazur for intel. "Brown manicures are basically the 'can’t go wrong' shade of the nail world. They’re warm, neutral, and somehow go with everything—like the nail version of your favorite coffee or leather bag," she says. Mazur also highlights that brown nails are also incredibly easy to wear, as they never look overly bold or plain. Brown nails work well for any occasion and look particularly stunning when dressed up with gold jewelry. "That’s why people love them. Brown nails are timeless, cozy, and quietly confident—just like good coffee and great style," adds Mazur.

When it comes to the brown manicures that have caught her eye recently, Mazur has been especially drawn to manicures created with taupe brown. "It’s one of those shades that always look clean and elegant without trying too hard. It has a soft, neutral tone that goes with everything. It’s simple but never boring, just timeless and chic," she says. Her all-time favorite brown nail looks, however, use ganache brown: a deep, rich, chocolate shade. "There’s something about it that instantly makes nails look more refined, like the color was made for fall and winter light," she says. "It has that glossy, smooth finish that catches the eye but still keeps things classy."

What's the Best Brown Polish for Me?

Since beginning my career as a beauty editor, I've come across hundreds of brown nail polishes that look stunning against my skin that I once thought would be far from complementary. Hours spent swatching brown polish shades at the nail salon were definitely helpful, but so was understanding how the undertone of your skin can change how a nail polish looks once it's out of the bottle and on the nails. Mazur's biggest tip for landing on the best shade of brown? Matching the skin's undertone with the undertone of a brown polish.

For skin with cool undertones, Mazur recommends opting for brown nail polish shades with a tasteful touch of mauve, taupe, or espresso in them. "Those cooler tones bring out the natural contrast and look match your skin color," she explains. If your skin is neutral, however, consider trying anything from creamy beige-browns to deep truffle shades. For individuals with warm skin tones, try warm brown polish shades with caramel, amber, or milk chocolate shades. "They’ll make your skin glow and feel super harmonious," says Mazur.

Now that you know why you should consider wearing brown nails and how to choose the best brow nail polish shade, keep scrolling to see some of my favorite brown manicures (and the best nail products to create them).

The Best Brown Manicures

This mocha brown shade is the ideal option for anyone who prefers to keep things light and creamy. To create this nail look, London- and Barcelona-based nail artist Mateja Novakovic selected a polish with an ultra-glossy finish.

Mazur created this timeless manicure using Nails of the Day's Wonka Gel Polish ($14), a dusty brown color with warmth brimming below the surface. This would be a great choice for all skin tones since it's not too cold or warm.

The leather brown shade used by Julia Diogo to create this manicure for one of her favorite clients is a timeless dark chocolate color that's bold and elegant. Plus, the amount of shine it has rivals that of a diamond ring.

Feeling spicy? Opt for a shade like Bio Sculpture Gel's Nail Polish in Rosewood Stardust ($15). The opulent chocolate color is packed with a metallic shimmer and features subtle copper undertones.

Chestnut-brown manicures offer a creamy brown blend with a whisper of taupe. This one, by Novakovic, uses Manucurist's Nail Polish in Chestnut ($14). If you have skin with a cool undertone, you should already have it in your collection!

When it comes to nail shapes, almond is always in style. We're taking notes from a rich, chocolate manicure by international manicurist Georgia Rae. This nail polish is quickly becoming the color of the season.

The Best Brown Nail Designs

Eye-catching, color-block nails have also been experiencing a renaissance over the past few months. This one, by nail artist Queenie Nguyen, blends crisp white lines with negative space and a rich maroon shade.

Of all the elegant manicure patterns to try, tortoiseshell is one of the most versatile. Shelton's take on the moody print blends a rich, amber shade with an equally luxe chocolate shade to create the flecks.

I'll always love traditional French manis, but have you tried playing around with texture? This elegant brown nail look features a deep caramel tone at the tips to add warmth while a blanket of velvet shimmer catches the light.

Who says you have to pick just one brown polish shade at a time to create nail art? This fall-inspired look by Bristol-based nail artist Charlotte Cliff uses at least four shades of brown with a gold chrome finish added to the third finger.

We're not done with brown-based tortoiseshell prints just yet. This nail look by Nguyen layers amber and espresso tones that make a statement while also being timeless and on-trend.

I may not be the sportiest person I know, but I have an appreciation for neutral-toned nail looks that incorporate game day–inspired designs. This one, by Shelton, combines a caramel brown shade with white, black, and silver.

Shop Our Favorite Brown Nail Polish

Why Trust Who What Wear

At Who What Wear, we know that beauty isn't one-size-fits-all. Over the years, our editors have tested thousands of products—including skincare, makeup, haircare, and nails—while also working closely with trusted experts, like renowned dermatologists, celebrity makeup artists, and other leading industry insiders. Together, this ensures every guide is well-researched, inclusive, and relevant to you.

We focus on formulas that deliver, whether they're affordable favorites or luxury investments. Our product selection is based on tangible results, ingredient know-how, and what we'd truly recommend to our closest friends and family members.