There's a strong chance you, like me, have a range of T-shirts stored in your wardrobe. Hey, you may even have the perfect one. If so, amazing, but if you're on the hunt for that ideal tee or are open to testing out something fresh, what's coming your way could be particularly intriguing. That's right—I spent the afternoon scrolling through a range of tees across a variety of retailers to uncover the best of the best silhouettes—focusing on those more neutral classic cuts that are slightly fitted and not overly oversized.
Given that there are so many good T-shirts out there, I found my A+ curation by diving into the review section to uncover those specific cuts that have positive comments with over four stars and above. Keep scrolling to check out the styles in question. You'll also notice that I pulled out an actual customer review for each to showcase the tees a bit more.
H&M
T-Shirt
"This may just be a basic T-shirt, but I love it! Super cheap, but good quality. Bought it in every color and print."—HMcustomer
Hanes
Nano T-Shirt
"While most sellers describe their product as being the best, I just received this T-shirt and I have to tell you, I have never had a nicer shirt. The material is as soft as can be, it fits perfectly, it hangs just right. I will always order these shirts, as I'm more than likely will wear them out. Thank you for such a great product."—Luvoshan
Madewell
Whisper Cotton Rib-Crewneck Tee
"I bought this on a whim when I heard Madewell updated the tee. It's a tad thicker, has a nice structured collar, and drapes to perfection. Highly recommend buying in every color!"—Kmmm
BP.
Crewneck T-Shirt
"Well fitting, nice material, comfy, and cute T-shirt."—Dchills
Eloquii
Rolled Cuff Easy Tee
"Comfy, stylish, good for lounging!"—Cassied
The Drop
Courtney Short-Sleeve T-Shirt
"I bought a couple of these tees for my daughter and she likes them a lot. The fabric is soft cotton that launders well and is pretty sturdy too. I would definitely recommend to others."—Peggy
Everlane
The Organic Cotton Crew
"A great staple to have, soft organic cotton that feels good and looks good!"—Rebecca_W
ATM
Cotton Crewneck T-Shirt
"Love it, color and fit."—Abilili
J.Crew
New Perfect Fit Tee
"I live in tees and this line is great. Not too thin, great quality, and fit. Fitted without being tight at all."—Sueshopsnordys
Re/Done
Classic Tee
"Great classic T-shirt, great quality."—Lisette09
Amazon Essentials
T-Shirt
"I bought 3 colors! These shirts fit great, are not clingy, and are super flattering!"—PZ
Frame
Le Scoop T-Shirt
"This tee is pricy but worth it, especially if you can get a sale price. It's soft, drapes well, not see-through, and the V-neck is not too low. It's a keeper. I usually take a medium but ordered a large and it fits beautifully."—Lulu82143
LNA
Essential Shaden Crew Neck Tee
"Super soft, perfect fit. Not see thru at all. Love this and ordering in more colors!"—AJNYC
Z Supply
Perfect V Tee
"It washes up nicely and doesn't stretch out."—Insider
AllSaints
Emelyn Tonic Tee
"Not see through, bought in size a small, fits perfectly. Can wear with anything, not sloppy looking."—Dolld
1901
Crewneck Cotton Blend Top
"Soft, comfy tee. Read other reviews and ordered a size up from my usual. Glad I did as the larger size fits great."—Elb206
Zella
Peaceful Twist T-Shirt
"LOOVE this top!! The material is sooo soft and it fit perfectly!"—Mitz85
Rag & Bone
The Tee
"Love this T-shirt as it is the second time I have bought a Rag & Bone T-shirt. Fitted but not too tight. I usually wear a small or a medium in shirts, and the medium is a perfect fit, so if in between sizes I would size up."—Klo78
Mott & Bow
Fitted Marcy Tee
"I like how soft the cotton is, and also a good fit."—LiliP
Kotn
Essential Crew
"The softest shirt that's ever graced my skin. True to size. Will definitely purchase more as needed."—Charmaine M
Splendid
Deep U-Neck Tee
"Comfortable, flattering, and cute."—HJBD
Monrow
Granite Jersey Crew Neck Tee
"I got this shirt today. I love it so much. The quality is very good. It fits well in my size M. It's exactly what I was looking for. I am very happy with it."—Netti
Lark & Ro
T-Shirt
"Scoop-neck tees are hard to find for some reason, so I'm very glad these shirts are so nice. They aren't thin, cheap material. I will probably be buying more."—Sara
Amazon Essentials
2-Pack Slim-Fit Cap-Sleeve Scoopneck T-Shirts
"Great fit! Feels soft. Buying other colors!"—FromFlorida
Bobby Schuessler is a fashion editor with over a decade of editorial experience covering shopping, style, and beauty. He's spent 10 years at Who What Wear, currently leading the market team to deliver highly covetable and convertible content. He creates data-driven shopping guides featuring top retailers like Nordstrom, Shopbop, and Net-a-Porter and is at the forefront of Who What Wear's shopping tentpole strategies, including Amazon Prime Day. He also works on branded content initiatives and appears on camera in video and shopping livestream franchises.