First Dates Always Lead to a Second When I Wear This
To be honest, I’m kind of a romantic at heart, but I often find today’s dating world to be hard to navigate. In fashion, I’m not often meeting people at work, and online dating apps can be overwhelming, often requiring a lot of work without leading to many great dates. So, when I do have a first date I’m excited about, I want to ensure I feel great, and that confidence often starts with what I’m wearing. Fortunately, I’ve narrowed in on a few perfect first-date outfits that always lead to a second date (when I want one, of course).
One of my go-to outfits is a midi-length dress with an interesting neckline. I tend to go for a dress past the knee because I prefer to skip anything super short. To balance it out though, I’ll be sure it has pretty details on top—like a sweetheart neckline or barely-there straps that make the piece feel special and worthy of a fun date.
My second outfit option follows that same train of thinking. If I’m not in the mood to wear a dress, I’ll instead turn to separates. If I want to slip into jeans, I’ll opt for something like a square-neck T-shirt or a nouveau milkmaid top. Same thing goes for a skirt where I’ll pair a bustier with a slip skirt (again in a below-the-knee length).
I have a theory on why these are such great first date outfits. To me, it’s about what they communicate. They’re equal parts modest and flirty, appropriate and romantic—so they strike all the right notes for a first night out together, in my opinion. Ahead, I’m breaking down some of my winning first date outfits that have led to second dates. They haven’t steered me wrong yet.
outfit option 1: a midi dress with interesting details
This is one of my newest finds and think it will be a date-night staple.
I love that the long sleeves and below-the-knee hemline balance out the deep V-neck cut.
This dress has a flattering neckline and some subtle slits up the sides that make it feel special.
outfit option 2: pants or a skirt + a top with a pretty neckline
I'm in love with square-neck tops, and they're the perfect thing to wear for a casual first date.
I wrote a story about how I always get asked out when I wear this outfit, but it also works as a great first-date look.
This corset-inspired top has quickly become a date night staple.
Shop my edit of more pieces to wear on a first date:
Next: I always get asked out when I wear this one outfit.
Kristen Nichols is the Associate Director, Special Projects at Who What Wear where she oversees luxury, runway content, and wedding features, and covers fashion within the luxury market, runway reporting, shopping features, trends, and interviews with leading industry experts. Kristen has worked with brands including Prada, Chanel, and Tiffany & Co., and her style has been featured in publications including Vogue.com, Vogue France, WWD, and the CFDA. Kristen began her career at Rodarte, where she worked on styling, photo shoots, and runway shows, and at Allure, where she moved into print and digital editorial. She graduated from the University of Southern California, where she studied art history and business, and currently lives in New York.
-
If Minimal Effort, Maximum Style Is Your Vibe, Then These 29 Cool Items from Gap Deserve a Spot in Your Outfit Rotation
NYC It girls shop here.
-
Suki Waterhouse Talks to Her Clothes and Thinks They Gain Special Powers When You Wear Them Again and Again
The singer and actress stars in Free People’s latest campaign.
-
This Dated Denim Pairing Is Suddenly the Chicest Way to Wear Jeans for Fall 2025
Easy and stylish.
-
The Specific Way Everyone Stylish in NYC Will Be Wearing Boots With Jeans This Fall
It's all about this styling trick.
-
I'm an NYC-Based Dad Who Is Always on the Move—This Is How I Redefined My Everyday Wear
Effortless, easy, and cool.
-
Ignore the Haters—I Still Love These Versatile and Comfy Pants and Bet You Do Too
See how fashion people from NYC to Paris to London wear them for fall.
-
Everything Who What Wear Editors Saw, Wore, Did, and Ate During NYFW
Let's dive in, shall we?
-
Paris Hilton's World: Her Pink Motorola Razr, Favorite Y2K Looks, and What 11:11 Media Means to Her
A glimpse into the life of this savvy entrepreneur.
-
This Classic Shoe Is Every Parisian's Secret to Making Jeans Look Elevated in Fall
And you probably already own it.
-
The Easy-Yet-Elevated Outfit Formula Fashion People Will Be Wearing Straight Into Fall
Here are seven takes on the chic look.