Straight From My Closet: My Favorite Flat Shoes and How They Look On

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668637862161-main

(Image credit: @allypayer)

I really love shoes. I love them so much that it's pretty much part of my personality. I often even plan entire outfits around what shoes I want to wear that day and admittedly spend more on shoes than probably any other category in my wardrobe. When designing my closet with The Container Store, I expressed to them that one of the most important aspects of my closet was that I had adequate space for shoes (and bags, but that's another story).

While it would be fun to have a reason to wear heels every day, I don't, and instead spend the majority of my time in flats. I'm lumping flats, sneakers, and flat boots together when I say that. They're all technically flats in my book. I always like to see what shoes look like IRL, whether I'm shopping for a new pair or am just curious, so I tried some of my favorite flat shoes on for you in case the same applies to you.

Scroll to see my go-to flats IRL, and shop them (or similar pairs) for your own shoe wardrobe.

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638954055-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

It makes me quite happy that the number one It shoe of 2022 is a flat one. As someone who grew up going to ballet class, I couldn't resist these. I chose the pink pair because they made me the most nostalgic. But perhaps the best thing about these is that they're so comfortable they basically feel like slippers.

Shop Miu Miu Ballerinas:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638955372-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

While I love the ballet flat trend, it's loafers that are nearest and dearest to my heart. I wear them with everything, so investing in them is always worth it to me. I got this Saint Laurent pair soon after it came out, and it's become one of the most-worn pairs of shoes in my closet.

Shop Saint Laurent Le Loafers:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638952019-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

As far as flats go, these are my most prized possession. They're so beautiful and elegant, and they make whatever I wear them with look chic. I will say that they're not great for long journeys on foot, but otherwise, they're lovely for day or night.

Shop Chanel Slingbacks:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638950566-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

I somehow got my hands on these at retail price before they sold out, and I feel very lucky. I love a fashion-y twist on an already trendy sneaker. I want to wear them all the time, but I also want to keep them pristine—the struggle is real.

Shop Adidas Originals by Wales Bonner Samba Sneakers:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638952455-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

G.H.Bass makes the best affordable loafers on the market, in my humble shoe-obsessed opinion. This two-tone pair is fun yet really classic. I love wearing them with everything from jeans to miniskirts.

Shop G.H.Bass Whitney Weejuns:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638953550-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

What can I say? I love a good sneaker collab. Pretty much everyone I know is obsessed with On sneakers, and pretty much every fashion person I know is obsessed with Loewe (myself included), so I couldn't think of a more genius matchup. And good news—the unlikely duo just dropped another batch of epic sneakers.

Shop Loewe x On Sneakers:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638954931-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

Rothy's is known for its wildly comfortable flats, and when I discovered it had a pair of on-trend Mary Janes, I had to try them. I still can't get over how cute (and yes, comfortable) they are.

Shop Rothy's The Square Mary Jane:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638952941-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

An oldie but goodie here. I got these Gucci loafers several years ago (as in, when they were hundreds of dollars cheaper than they are now), and I'd honestly rebuy them at the current price. I've worn them countless times at this point. They required zero breaking in. I could sing their praise all day.

Shop Gucci Jordaan Loafers:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638954431-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

I held out on ordering these for as long as I could because I hate paying resale prices for shoes, but I finally caved and ordered them from StockX. Hopefully they'll stay cool forever, but I may never stop wearing them either way.

Shop Aimé Leon Dore New Balance 550 Sneakers:

favorite-flat-shoes-303790-1668638951396-image

(Image credit: @allypayer)

Birkenstock Boston Clogs are pretty tough to find these days, but don't give up. This blingy Manolo Blahnik collab pair is sold out, but I found a similar one for you (that will also probably sell out). 

Shop Birkenstock Boston Clogs:

Next up, five popular shoe trends the fashion crowd is wearing with dresses.

Allyson Payer
Senior Editor

Allyson is a senior editor for Who What Wear. She joined the company in 2014 as co-founder Katherine Power's executive assistant and over the years has written hundreds of stories for Who What Wear. Prior to her career in fashion, Allyson worked in the entertainment industry at companies such as Sony Pictures Television. Allyson is now based in Raleigh, North Carolina, and is originally from Baton Rouge, Louisiana. She holds a BFA in theater. Her path to fashion may not have been linear, but based on the number of fashion magazines she collected as a child and young adult, it was meant to be.