37 Pairs of Under-$150 Heels I'd Actually Wear Out in NYC

On Sylvie Mus: Madewell The Milano Heeled Sandal ($148)
New York really does a number on your footwear. Between the subway stairs at Union Square and the delightful-yet-disastrous cobblestones outside some of my favorite restaurants, the scuffs are inevitable. To avoid heartbreak, I'm very open to keeping affordable styles in the mix.
When it comes to reasonably priced footwear, I always start with Mango for highly covetable, gently on-trend takes on classic styles that always get compliments. I have to say that both Zara and H&M are currently really on one with genuine leather styles that are extremely designer coded. As always, Nordstrom is serving up a slew of options from wallet-friendly brands like Jeffrey Campbell and Franco Sarto. From chic burgundy slingbacks and classic Mary Janes to animal-print mules and trendy heeled loafers, these under-$150 shoes are truly punching way above their price tags.

Natalie Cantell is an NYC-based style director, creative consultant, and fashion editor, who regularly contributes from Paris. She was the executive director of Who What Wear and Marie Claire’s brand studio until 2023, and now freelances globally on shoots, stories, and special projects.
-
I'm a Shopping Director—Simply Put, Here's a Fall Shopping List Filled With Chic, Cool, and Fun Items
Gorgeous sweaters, sleek jackets, beauty staples, and more.
-
Here They Are: The 6 Biggest Boot Trends of Fall 2025
Exotic finishes! Sock boots! Western motifs!
-
Ignore the Haters—I Still Love These Versatile and Comfy Pants and Bet You Do Too
See how fashion people from NYC to Paris to London wear them for fall.
-
My Mom Only Shops Affordable Fashion—I Sent Her These 27 Chic Rich-Looking Pieces for Fall 2025
Everything is under $100.
-
If Reading Brontë in Central Park Is Your Vibe, Then You're Going to Love These 28 Fall Sweaters From Gap, Old Navy, and Banana Republic
Striped sweaters and cashmere.
-
Wait, J.Crew Is 30% Off Sitewide Right Now—These Are the Chic Fall Pieces in My Cart
The fall 2025 collection is so good.
-
After 2 Weeks in Italy, I'm Convinced I Need the Shoe Trend Every Chic Woman in Milan and Rome Was Wearing
Forget ballet flats.
-
Shopbop Lovers to the Front—These 40 Styles Are Going to Be Huge This Fall
Give your wardrobe a fall facelift.