The Top-Rated Black Heels at the Stores You Actually Shop

The Best Black Heels With Top Reviews


Getty Images

If you were to name off the workhorses in your shoe rotation, black heels would undoubtedly rank high on your list. While you may have a variety of pairs you wear to work and/or out with friends, do you have the pair? Well, let’s figure that out. There’s clearly a plethora of options out there from just about every store imaginable, but to zero in on the absolute best styles, we pulled the top-rated black heels from the places you actually shop. Here, we’re talking the most popular, stylish, and comfortable silhouettes from stores like Amazon and Shopbop. Okay, enough talking and more shopping. Keep scrolling to find your perfect new pair of pumps that have the best customer reviews.


5 out of 5

"My foot is medium-sized width, and it's difficult to find pointy-toed shoes that fit and feel comfortable too."

5 out of 5

"LOVE these pumps. They fit true to size and were comfortable right out of the box, which is not always the case with heels."

5 out of 5

"My favorite go-to pump for dresses and pants. Manageable heel for everyday. Need them in every color. The toe box is cut high so looks flattering on foot. Fits true to size."

5 out of 5

"Beautiful heel with a twist, yet still extremely classy!"

5 out of 5

"Great style as always expected from Via, comfortable and fashion-forward, sharp design, love it."


5 out of 5

"These are the perfect shoe for day to night wear. They add the perfect feminine touch and will dress up jeans and a T-shirt. I wore them straight out of the box to a concert where I was standing for three hours, and they were really comfortable."

5 out of 5

"These are the perfect classic black pumps. They're a good height and super comfortable. Great for both work and going out."

5 out of 5

"If you love a little cute shoe with a reasonable heel height you might want to order these before the holidays."

4 out of 5

"Very nice-looking shoes, pretty comfortable."

5 out of 5

"Great shoes, just black and classy. Ideal shape and perfect heel height. Very comfortable!"


4.8 out of 5

"This shoe is not only beautiful but comfortable. I have a wide foot, and it's very hard to find a pump that is comfortable and also looks great!"

5 out of 5

"These shoes are fabulous! They are sexy and comfortable! The leather is a supple luxurious leather, the heel is a perfect height for dressy evening wear, cocktails, or a pantsuit."

4.4 out of 5

"These pumps are gorgeous and super high-quality, which I would expect from Coach. They look beautiful on the feet, and reveal a tiny bit of toe cleavage."

5 out of 5

"I have these shoes in several colors, and I absolutely love them for the office. They are comfortable and look great with dresses and suits."


4.8 out of 5 stars

"Love this shoe! I bought the shoe to wear to a wedding."

4.7 out of 5

"Well, I can't say enough good about this shoe. Edelman makes some great shoes but this, well, the shape, lift, and profile of the shoe is unsurpassed."

5 out of 5 stars

"I love this shoe and have it in so many colors! The design of the shoe provides great support, with a confident, sexy look."

4.6 out of 5 Stars

"I was very apprehensive about buying heels from Amazon, but I love these so much! They're exactly what I was looking for: Heel height at least 4 inches, round toe, and NO PLATFORM! I hate platforms. These are so hard to find."

4.9 out of 5

"As usual, Nine West has outdone themselves, this shoe is perfect for the office, it is classy but has a nice kick to the colored inserts on both the front of the shoe and the heel, very sophisticated!"

Related Stories