I Personally Guarantee These 25 Products Live Up to Their 5-Star Ratings

Let's face it—there are a lot of beauty products with 5-star reviews out there. Should we give credence to Debby from Arizona's rave review? Unclear. So, I asked people I trust greatly (read: my colleagues and yours truly) to share which highly-rated products they've actually tried and would gush about just as hard as random reviewer #249.

I happened to do this little exercise on products from Dermstore, a retailer beauty editors swear by for the best in skincare. Scroll down to see the products myself and my trusted fellow beauty experts would give top marks to—from the disgusting yet gratifying foot treatment to the hair towel that is "seriously life-changing" with the before and after photos to prove it.



(Image credit: @katcollings)



(Image credit: @katcollings)



(Image credit: @katcollings)

Left: Air-dry without any products

Right: Air-dry with the Aquis hair turban and Living Proof leave-in conditioner



(Image credit: @katcollings)
Editor in Chief

Kat Collings has over 15 years of experience in the editorial fashion space, largely in digital publishing. She currently leads the vision for editorial content at WhoWhatWear.com as the site's editor in chief, having risen through the editorial ranks after joining the company in 2012. Collings is a Digiday Future Leader Awards nominee, was named Buzzfeed's best fashion Instagram accounts of the year, and is a member of the CFDA Awards Fashion Guild. Prior to Who What Wear, Collings worked on styling projects for brands such as Vogue, Teen Vogue, Lucky, and Oliver Peoples. She graduated from UCLA with a BA in communications and calls Los Angeles home.