13 J.Crew Swimsuits With Incredible Reviews

Photo:

J.Crew

When you're in need of a swimsuit, J.Crew is always one of your best bets. There's a wide selection of styles, sizes, and silhouettes in classic solids and prints alike, and you can usually score a deal with one of the retailer's generous discount codes. Plus, since they tend to skew classic rather than super-duper trendy, you'll find they last years—especially if you're the type who mostly breaks out your bathing suits for poolside lounging.

More active beachgoers will also find an impressive array of full-coverage pieces, from surf-ready rash guards to cute, coordinating board shorts. But how to know what style to choose without enduring the harsh realities of trying on bikinis in a fitting room in the winter? J.Crew's review system has you covered. We scoured the site for the top-reviewed items—tops, bottoms, one-pieces, and specialty-sized suits for DD cups and those with long torsos. 

Below, see 13 swimsuits J.Crew customers love (and feel extra confident knowing the retailer offers free shipping and free returns on all swim!).

4.6/5 stars, 26 reviews, recommended by 96%

For those looking for a snug and secure fit, this top is a winner. Thanks to the adjustable ties, says one reviewer, the suit "is incredibly comfortable (no digging into your neck or shoulders)."

4/5 stars, 26 reviews, recommended by 81%

"I love how this suit looks like a two-piece from the back, with the front providing stylish coverage," raves one reviewer. Plus, it comes with an optional halter strap if that’s more your speed.

4/5 stars, 3 reviews, recommended by 100%

Reviewers recommend these easy-to-wear bottoms for their "spot-on" fit and "not-too-skimpy" coverage.

Shop the matching top here

4.8/5 stars, 6 reviews, recommended by 100%

For those who want to cover up at the beach (sun safety FTW!) or swim in chillier waters, this long-sleeve style is a great choice.

4.7/5 stars, 19 reviews, recommended by 89%

This bikini top must be magic because it seems to flatter just about everyone who buys it. Reviewers who wear C- and D-cups praise the fact that there’s "no awkward side boob/under boob/cleavage" (score!) while less busty girls say it accentuates the chest without looking like a push-up bra.

4.5/5 stars, 15 reviews, recommended by 100%

Swimsuit shopping is tricky, so when reviewer after reviewer calls one "perfect," we’re bound to listen up. And the best part about this cool asymmetrical style? It seems to flatter a wide range of body types.

4/5 stars, 24 reviews, recommended by 79%

Fans of this string bikini are especially impressed by it’s "so soft" fabric and removable pads. "Every year the only decision is...what color?" writes one. And with nine to choose from, we can understand the dilemma.

4.2/5 stars, 53 reviews, recommended by 85%

Shoppers sing the praises of this ’90s-inspired swimsuit, which J.Crew brought back from its archives in 2014. The high-cut legs and open back offer "just the right amount of sexy."

4.6/5 stars, 26 reviews, recommended by 88%

One 26-year-old reviewer really nails the appeal of these well-cut, high-quality bottoms when she says, "These are a very happy middle-ground between the itsy-bitsy teeny-weeny swimsuits marketed to girls a few years younger than me and the geriatric suits designers seem to think come with the next stages of life."

Shop the matching top here

4.6/5 stars, 28 reviews, recommended by 96%

"Tall gals rejoice!" reads one review, and just about every other echoes the sentiment. This strapless suit is comfy, flattering, and manages to stay on even in the waves. Not an easy feat!

4.4/5 stars, 27 reviews, recommended by 88%

The words used most by reviewers are "flattering" and "classic," which seems right on point for this stylish one-piece.

4.5/5 stars, 15 reviews, recommended by 93%

Bustier shoppers are big fans of this super-flattering one-piece. One reviewer, who wears a 40G, even says the thick straps and fuller front are enough to ensure "good coverage" and "no spillage."

Ready for warmer temps? You're not the only one. Don't miss the swimsuit styles seven top influencers are snatching up this season.