I Ordered 3 Under-$50 Basics From Amazon on a Whim—Here's My Honest Review

Ordering basics on Amazon isn't something I'd say is easy, as far as shopping is concerned. The options are vast, and things can quickly get overwhelming, but I'm here to help. My number one tip is to narrow down the offerings to Amazon Fashion's in-house brands. Many of its brands happen to be basics-heavy brands, and in my experience, the quality is surprisingly good given the price point.
While poking around in Amazon Fashion recently, on one of the first crisp fall days of the year, I added three basics that caught my eye to my cart: a fluffy gray sweater, a pair of dark-wash straight-leg jeans, and a thick fleece pullover that looks like something I might've swiped from my husband's closet (in a good way). Upon their arrival at my doorstep two days later, I was so happy with my purchases that I decided to write some reviews. Keep scrolling for my unfiltered thoughts about the items and shop them for yourself.
The Item:
Daily Ritual Women's Teddy Bear Fleece Quarter Zip JacketPrice:
$49
My review: You wouldn't really know by looking at the picture on the model, but this fleece pullover (I'm wearing a size small) is surprisingly thick and cozy. In fact, I would recommend it as more of a jacket than a sweatshirt for indoors. The fleece has a nice, full texture, and I found it to look very well made and not as bulky as I thought it would be upon taking it out of the package. My only complaint would be that instead of being lined with the fleece material, it has a polyester lining that isn't quite as nice, but it's not a dealbreaker.
Also wearing: Totême hat; Madewell x Kule Relaxed Dadjean (currently unavailable, shop similar); Clergerie Gillef Sherpa Slippers ($417)
Shop the fleece:
The Item:
Goodthreads Boucle Shaker Stitch Balloon-Sleeve SweaterPrice:
$40
My review: I donated a lot of sweaters at the end of last winter, so I've been in need of a refresh of some basic styles. This one instantly caught my eye, with its chic mock neck and slightly puffed sleeves. Here, I'm wearing a size small. Gray is trending this fall, so that's what I went with. When I unboxed it, my first thought was how soft it was. It's fluffy and warm but also lightweight enough to tuck it in. It's also a great length (for reference, I'm 5'4") and looks cute with skinny jeans and ankle boots, as you can see.
Also wearing: J Brand jeans; BY FAR boots
Shop the sweater:
The Item:
Daily Ritual High-Rise Slim Straight JeansPrice:
$39
My review: Designer denim is expensive for a reason—it's made with quality materials and is expertly stitched. With that in mind, it's understandable that affordable denim can be hit-or-miss. But hoping for a hit, I took the plunge and ordered this pair (in a size 26, for reference). I liked that they were slightly loose on the model. They were closer to a pair of skinny jeans on me, so if I were to order them again, I think I'd go up a size for a more relaxed fit. They're quite stretchy (and comfortable), but in the several hours that I wore them, they didn't stretch out all that much. My verdict is that I'd recommend, but go up a size if you want a fit similar to how they look on the model.
Also wearing: Dôen Rune Top ($190); Prada Logo Platform Loafers ($850)
Shop the jeans:
Shop More Stylish Amazon Basics
Next up: 42 Things You Have to See From Nordstrom, Amazon, and Shopbop Right Now

Allyson is a senior editor for Who What Wear. She joined the company in 2014 as co-founder Katherine Power's executive assistant and over the years has written hundreds of stories for Who What Wear. Prior to her career in fashion, Allyson worked in the entertainment industry at companies such as Sony Pictures Television. Allyson is now based in Raleigh, North Carolina, and is originally from Baton Rouge, Louisiana. She holds a BFA in theater arts. Her path to fashion may not have been linear, but based on the number of fashion magazines she collected as a child and young adult, it was meant to be.
-
It's Now or Never—54 Last-Minute Amazon Prime Day Deals You'll Regret Skipping
Elevated basics, celeb dupes, luxe-like styles, and more on sale.
-
If You Have Amazon Prime Day FOMO, See What Our Fashion and Beauty Editors Actually Bought This Year
The sale ends today.
-
Last Call: These 5 Amazon Prime Deals Are the Best of the Best
It's your last chance to get these amazing styles for less.
-
If You're Anti-Heels, Stand Up: 21 Stunning Flat Shoes and Sneakers on Sale for Amazon Prime Day 2025
Refresh your shoe closet for les
-
I Shop for a Living—These 30 Elevated Fashion, Beauty, and Home Décor Picks From the Amazon Prime Day Sale Have My Attention
Chic, practical, and affordable.
-
I Spoke With Sofia Richie Grainge About Her New Amazon Line—These 23 Children's Items Are So Cute
If you're looking for chic baby clothes.
-
Oh Wow, Hailey Bieber's Go-To Denim Brand Is on Major Sale During Amazon Prime Day
Don't miss out.
-
If You Have Toteme Taste But an Amazon Budget, These Are the $32 Classic Heels You Need This Prime Day
They look identical to the designer pair Hailey Bieber keeps wearing.