Per Our Editors' Group Chats, These Are the Best Colognes a Man Can Wear

For a long-lasting citrus option, consider something like this Aesop pick. "My partner has to be one of the pickiest people of the planet about fragrances, so I love seeing what passes his barometer," says associate shopping editor Audry Hiaoui. "I put him onto Aesop's Tacit, which he now wears regularly."

Pro: Long-lasting

Con: None

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Yuzu, basil grand vert, clove middle notes, rosemary, mint, fennel, cedarwood, vetiver heart, amber

Scent Profile: Citrus

Customer review: "This is a very masculine scent but it’s incredible!! I sprayed it in the air to test the scent and I can smell the basil and vetiver. It’s perfect for a casual date night or business environment. I absolutely love the way the scent mixes with my husbands natural body scent."

My partner wears this Versace cologne often, and it's easily my favorite on him. Although it contains vanilla, it doesn't overpower the other notes. It truly is a warm fragrance, and I'm always impressed by how long it lasts throughout the day. The scent is definitely masculine-leaning, but it's still youthful and fresh. Some people like powdery colognes, but I personally love how rich this one is.

Pros: Easy to layer, long-lasting

Cons: Bottle can crack easily

Type: Eau De Toilette

Key Notes: Mint leaves, orange blossom, vanilla madagascar

Scent Profile: Warm and spicy

Customer review: "I gifted this to my husband on his birthday, and it has become one of his favorite fragrances. The scent is vibrant, with a mix of fresh citrus and warm, slightly sweet notes. He usually saves it for date nights or occasions when he wants to stand out."

Le Labo is known for high-demand fragrances, so it didn't surprise me when this pick entered the group chat. "My fiancé is on the hunt for a good wedding fragrance, but usually he wears Tonka by Le Labo," says associate features editor Ana Escalante. Hiaoui is also a fan. Although it's a bit up there in price, the fresh blend of woody and musky notes makes it worth every penny. But if you'd rather put a feeler out there, you can also buy a mini set and test out a few options before fully committing.

Pros: Fresh

Cons: Pricey

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Orange flower absolute, cedar atlas, styrax resins, absolute tonka, musks

Scent Profile: Woody and musky

If you need a cologne for a special occasion, look no further than this warm and spicy cologne from Tom Ford. "My husband wears either Tom Ford Ombre Leather (what he wore to our wedding) or Le Labo The Noir," says senior beauty editor Jamie Schneider. "Both of which I often steal." This bold scent is long-lasting and easy to layer, making it well-worth the investment.

Pros: Unisex, long-lasting

Cons: Some say it's too strong

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Black leather, violet flower, jasmine flower

Scent Profile: Warm and spicy

Customer review: "This has been the absolute best scent. My partner smells like a sexy version of “new high end car” and I frankly can’t get enough of it. I will be repurchasing this because it’s so elevated and masculine."

For a mature and confident scent that's still vibrant try this Prada cologne, which has the perfect blend of earthy, citrus, and woody notes. "My dad likes a strong scent that commands a room—it feels like he wants to walk in and let it be known he's there," says Hiaoui. "I recently gifted him this Prada one, and he told me he got so many compliments when he wore it."

Pros: Long-lasting

Cons: Some think it's too sweet

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Bergamot, geranium, ambery woods

Scent Profile: Earthy, citrus, and woody

Customer review: "My husband loved this fragrance. So clean and fresh. I will for sure buy the full size bottle. I love all Prada products but this went through the gate!"

Open to splurging? If so, this woody gourmand cologne from Parfums de Marly won't disappoint. It contains notes of bergamot, lavender, clary sage, saffron, and leather (just to name a few). "I got my dad Parfums de Marly's Haltane as a gift, and he loves it," says Schneider. "He says he always gets compliments."

Pros: Rich, bold, long-lasting

Cons: Expensive

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Bergamot, lavender, clary sage, saffron, praline, natural agarwood (oud), leather, cedar

Scent Profile: Woody gourmand

In case you didn't know, Zara also sells fragrances. And according to the group chat, there are plenty of underrated and affordable options worth looking into. "Don't sleep on Zara colognes—they're really good. They have a lot of good dupes," says Escalante, whose partner wears this Seoul 532-8 Sinsa Dong Gangnam-Gu.

Pros: Highly affordable

Cons: Some say it doesn't last long

Type: Eau de Toilette

Key Notes: Hazelnut, pepper, amber

Scent Profile: Warm and spicy

If you want a confident cologne that's less citrus-forward and more spice-heavy, you'll love Armani Beauty's Code. It's especially nice for those who prefer a powdery finish. "This one and Burberry Touch are my dad's top two favorites," says Hiaoui. "The Armani is good for people who want long-lasting something more long-lasting."

Pros: Sustainably sourced

Cons: None

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Green mandarin, nutmeg, tonka bean 

Scent Profile: Ambery Spicy

Customer review: "Love the longevity and scent intensity, doesn't come off too strong. Gives that nice clean, light powdery, spicy, citrusy smell. Quite a large bottle size too."

To cast a wider net, I reached out to a few long-time friends of mine to see which colognes they've recently gravitated towards. One stand out was YLS's Myslf. "I like scents that give you a warm feeling and make you feel at home," one friend told me. "The longevity is pretty good—it lasts a few hours." This bold scent has a well-rounded blend of citrus and woody notes, making it a true standout. Plus, it's relatively affordable compared to some of the other options on our list.

Pros: Easy to layer, long-lasting

Cons: Some find it too strong

Type: Eau De Parfum

Key Notes: Orange blossom aboslute, woods accord, vanilla bourbon

Scent Profile: Citrus and woody

Customer review: "Absolutely love this cologne! Got my husband the gift set and it smells amazing on him and the scent lasts forever. Definitely a keeper!"

Another friend of mine called out Carolina Herrera's Bad Boy (the counterpart to the viral perfume Good Girl). He notes that it gets him far more compliments than some of his other colognes, and it has noticeably long lasting power. This fragrance has a classic blend of warm and spicy notes, making it a bit tricky to layer with other scents. That said, it's still an attention-grabber as is, so trust that it's worth it.

Pros: Well-balanced

Cons: Not ideal for layering

Type: Eau De Toilette

Key Notes: Grapefruit, white pepper, vetiver, clary sage, tonka bean, cocoa

Scent Profile: Warm and spicy

Customer review: "Bad Boy by Carolina Herrera is one of the most striking men's fragrances I've experienced — bold, confident, and unforgettable. From the first spray, it opens with an energetic burst of fresh and spicy notes that immediately wake the senses."