As with other areas in life, when it comes to fashion, my sister and I don't always see eye to eye. We aren't polar opposites in our fashion tastes by any means, but I tend to lean into classic, fashion-forward styling, whereas she stays in the trendier Gen Z space. This, of course, seems to reflect our difference in age, as there are seven years between us. If you were to also break down our favorite places to shop, the selections would be similar, especially with Nordstrom, Shopbop, and H&M.
With that in mind, my sister and I set out to do an online-shopping session with the goal of seeing what fall basics we will both be reaching for this season. First, we decided what categories we both had in mind. Think outerwear, flat shoes, sweaters, and more. From there, we scrolled through the different online stores until something caught our attention. Naturally, we left our shopping date with a virtual cart full of fall-ready finds.
Keep scrolling to check out all of the chic fall basics my sister and I would both buy this season.
Striped Sweaters
Me: Very into this whimsical color mix.
My Sister: I always get compliments when I wear this.
Me: I could live in this sweater.
My Sister: Perfect with jeans or leggings.
Me: The model sold me on this jacket.
My Sister: It looks great with the chain necklace.
Me: This sweater would be great with a maxi skirt.
My Sister: I'd wear this one with jeans.
Me: Picture this layered over a white slip skirt.
My Sister: I am always a fan of olive green.
Maxi Skirts
Me: This skirt looks cool with sneakers or boots.
My Sister: Love that you can easily dress it up or down.
Me: Very into this dark denim wash.
My Sister: The front slit is super chic.
Me: I can't believe this skirt is under $50.
My Sister: A black slip skirt is great year-round.
Me: Perfect with edgy moto boots.
My Sister: I'd wear this with a simple sweater.
Me: I love how Scandi women have been wearing these.
My Sister: There are so many ways to wear this skirt.
Tweed Jackets
Me: A French-girl staple.
My Sister: This looks expensive, but it's under $100.
Me: I could see Sofia Richie Grainge in this.
My Sister: The collar on this jacket is cool.
Me: I like the color.
My Sister: This one is so effortless.
Me: The styling here with denim is cool.
My Sister: It's giving me Chanel vibes.
Me: The gold buttons give this a luxe feel.
My Sister: Always great with T-shirts and jeans.
Black Ballet Flats
Me: The Row aesthetic.
My Sister: Great with jeans, skirts, and dresses.
Me: Classic black ballet flats.
My Sister: How are these under $20?
Me: Balletcore through and through.
My Sister: Edgy ballerina vibes for sure.
Me: Square-toe shoes are a personal favorite.
My Sister: These are super cute.
Me: These also come in a pretty pink.
My Sister: Giving me ballet class flashbacks.
Cargo Pants
Me: The color is what grabbed my attention.
My Sister: Great with black and white basics.
Me: A great black pant option this season.
My Sister: You can wear them with any shoes.
Me: I am obsessed with the cut and color.
My Sister: Love the minimal feel.
Me: I might have to cave on these jeans.
My Sister: Definite statement jeans.
Me: You could wear these to the office.
My Sister: Or for a night out!
Trench Coats
Me: I love the maxi length.
My Sister: Such a good find—most long trench coats are not usually not this affordable.
Me: A great switch-up from the usual trench.
My Sister: It looks designer.
Me: Proof that trenches instantly elevate a look.
My Sister: A belted look is alway chic.
Me: This is something to wear forever.
My Sister: And now, I want a black trench coat.
Me: A great layering piece no matter the season.
My Sister: This neutral tone is nice.
-
If Minimal Effort, Maximum Style Is Your Vibe, Then These 29 Cool Items from Gap Deserve a Spot in Your Outfit RotationNYC It girls shop here.
-
I Thought I Hated Ballet Flats Until I Found This Elegant (and Blister-Proof) PairNow, I need it in every color.
-
My Mom Only Shops Affordable Fashion—I Sent Her These 27 Chic Rich-Looking Pieces for Fall 2025Everything is under $100.
-
If Reading Brontë in Central Park Is Your Vibe, Then You're Going to Love These 28 Fall Sweaters From Gap, Old Navy, and Banana RepublicStriped sweaters and cashmere.
-
Loafers Are Great, But If You're Bored, This Is the Classic Flat Shoe Trend to Try NextCould this be the new It flat shoe for fall?
-
After 2 Weeks in Italy, I'm Convinced I Need the Shoe Trend Every Chic Woman in Milan and Rome Was WearingForget ballet flats.
-
Shopbop Lovers to the Front—These 40 Styles Are Going to Be Huge This FallGive your wardrobe a fall facelift.
-
I'm a Former Nordstrom Buyer—These Are the 8 Fall Trends I Care About, PeriodFrom an It jacket silhouette to a cool denim cut.
