Sarah Michelle Gellar Just Shared Her '90s Beauty Regrets, and They're Honestly So Relatable

Let's talk about eyebrows. The humble yet hotly contested feature is basically a visual reflection of the era we live in. In 2013, we yearned for big, fluffy brows. In 2016, we collectively embraced "Instagram eyebrows." Sometime circa 2022, we were all obsessed with soap brows. You get it.
With ever-changing aesthetics, it's only natural to look back on your previous looks and think, Yikes. We do. And apparently, so does Sarah Michelle Gellar. The Cruel Intentions and Buffy the Vampire Slayer actor recently filmed a GRWM video with beauty brand Merit. In it, she reflects on her personal beauty evolution, opening up about her '90s beauty blunders, including what she calls "sperm brows." Yep. Keep scrolling for her hilarious and relatable reflections.
Nineties kids will surely remember Gellar as Kathryn in Cruel Intentions. It was one of her most iconic roles, yet despite the cult status of the film, she cringes when she thinks back to the era because of one thing—yep, her eyebrows. "Do you ever look back at your old pictures and think, 'What was I thinking?'" she asks. "My biggest mistake from the '90s that I think everybody can agree with would be my sperm brows. That's right. I said it. My brows looked like sperm."
Hilarious? Yes. Relatable? Definitely. Thanks to some accompanying throwback photos that are provided on-screen, it's clear Gellar is referring to the thin, tapered brows that were omnipresent in the '90s. This picture of Gellar, taken in 1994, is a good example.
While we think she's being hard on herself (those brows were on-trend at the time!), we get the sentiment, especially now that fluffy, structured brows are the moment. These days, she uses a $44 brow duo to rectify her brow regrets.
"I finally figured out my eyebrows," Gellar says. She uses the Merit Brow Duo. It combines the brand's Brow 1980 Volumizing Eyebrow Gel-Pomade ($24) with the brand's new Brow 1990 Ultra Fine Eyebrow Gel Pencil ($24). The former is a nod to the soft, fluffy brow looks of the '80s. It delivers a light hold with zero flakes or crunchiness. The latter is a nod to the sleek brows of the '90s. It delivers natural-looking fullness and definition. When used together, these products polish and perfect the brows. And take it from us—they're virtually foolproof.
Oh, and as for her other '90s beauty regrets? She dishes on the disaster of bleached brows during her Buffy the Vampire Slayer days when her brows actually disintegrated from damage. Then, there was the time she dyed her hair a dark chestnut color and matched her eyebrows along with it. Finally, she can't forget how she "destroyed" her hair by dyeing it too often, which accidentally led to her "baby bangs" era.
She can rest assured that she's not the only one who's had a beauty mishap. We've had many. And even her husband, Freddie Prinze Jr., isn't excluded. "He had to dye his hair blonde for Scooby-Doo," she says, "and they dyed his eyebrows."
She ends the video with a swipe of Merit's Shade Slick Tinted Lip Oil in Beet ($24). "If you learn anything from my mistakes," she says, "less is always more."
5 More Editor-Loved Merit Products
This balm-like blush deposits sheer color that lets the skin show through.
This niacinamide and hyaluronic acid serum hydrates, plumps, and brightens the skin. Thanks to it's oil-and-water bi-phase formula, it delivers instantly glowy skin.
This foundation-and-concealer stick couldn't be easier to use (or blend).
These soft matte eye shadow pots are foolproof and deliver a pretty wash of color.
The Who What Wear beauty team loves Merit's lipstick formulas.

Kaitlyn McLintock is a Beauty Editor at Who What Wear. She has 10 years of experience in the editorial industry, having previously written for other industry-leading publications, like Byrdie, InStyle, The Zoe Report, Bustle, and others. She covers all things beauty and wellness-related, but she has a special passion for creating skincare content (whether that's writing about an innovative in-office treatment, researching the benefits of a certain ingredient, or testing the latest and greatest at-home skin device). Having lived in Los Angeles, California, and Austin, Texas, she has since relocated back to her home state, Michigan. When she's not writing, researching, or testing beauty products, she's working through an ever-growing book collection or swimming in the Great Lakes.
-
Spotted in Paris's Poshest Arrondissement: Kendall Jenner in the "Boring" Pants I Now Need
My baggy black trousers are going on hiatus.
By Allyson Payer
-
Prada, Dior, and Givenchy: I'm Crossing Off Items on My Luxury Beauty Wish List During This Short Sale
Here are my top 10 picks.
By Kaitlyn McLintock
-
Prada, Dior, and Givenchy: I'm Crossing Off Items on My Luxury Beauty Wish List During This Short Sale
Here are my top 10 picks.
By Kaitlyn McLintock
-
If I Could Only Use 15 Beauty Products, I'd Choose These
My essentials for glowing skin.
By Sasha Mironer
-
Hailey Bieber Applies This $20 Korean Jelly Blush on Top of Her Rhode Ones (so Now I Will Too)
It gives her soft, matte, and cloud-like skin.
By Kaitlyn McLintock
-
All Your Favorite Celebs Book This Lymphatic Drainage Expert Before Events—I Scored Her At-Home Tips
Genius de-puffing tricks ahead.
By Jamie Schneider
-
I Thought I Was Over This "Juvenile" Nail Color, But Rihanna Just Convinced Me Otherwise
Perfect for summer.
By Jamie Schneider
-
There's Nothing Stopping Ballerina Alicia Mae Holloway From Soaring to New Heights
This dancer is living life with no limits.
By Maya Thomas
-
Charli XCX Wore This New Designer "Puffer Gloss" While Performing at Coachella
It's selling out fast.
By Kaitlyn McLintock
-
Ava Phillippe on Her "Fantasy" Brunette Era and the $12 Lip Stain She Bought After Billie Eilish
Read our Unfiltered chat.
By Jamie Schneider