The Best Etsy Jewelry Stores for Unique Finds

If you are a lover of jewels, gems, and the like, you absolutely need to know about our picks for the best Etsy jewelry stores. Criteria for this site-wide search included many things. First was a wide selection and curation of strong pieces, not just a few standouts—the type of store where choosing just one item will be a challenge. Second, we looked for imagery that was eye-catching and forward. Because after all, a picture does say a thousand words. Lastly, in order to be the "best Etsy jewelry store," it needed to have unique pieces that you don't come across every day. 

Out of the thousands of jewelry sellers on Etsy, there were five stores that completely won our hearts. Whether you are on the hunt for a vintage-inspired engagement ring or simple minimalistic pieces, you better believe that you'll find exactly what you're looking for right here. 

Keep reading to discover the absolute best Etsy jewelry stores! 


This store offers a wide selection of unique and quirky vintage pieces that extend past just jewelry. Besides the few necklaces and bracelets sold by this retailer, statement earrings clearly steal the spotlight here. 


Lovers of all things minimalistic rejoice because this shop was made just for you. Simple yet striking jewelry is clearly Rebecca's specialty, and each piece is more special than the next. 


Capucinne has some of the most gorgeous pieces with shapes and stones that will make your jaw drop. But we particularly love their fresh take on the engagement ring. 


This shop is a curation of vintage pieces at extremely affordable price points. These are the kinds of jewelry pieces you'll want when your outfit is in need of some serious sprucing. 


Studio Cosette is where you should come when you are on the hunt for good-quality items that are still fun. Price points here are still relatively affordable when you consider what you are getting—14k gold, opals, and more. 

Lauren Eggertsen
Editorial Director

"Copy (200 words): Lauren Eggertsen is currently the editorial director of Who What Where and has worked at the company for nearly seven years, where she started as an associate editor and has since worked her way up. Lauren has over 10 years of experience in the fashion editorial space, starting her career with internships at Marc Jacobs, Marie Claire, and The Zoe Report, where she was later hired as their editorial assistant. Lauren has worked in the Los Angeles and New York Who What Wear offices but currently calls L.A. home. It is here where she leads and manages Who What Wear's fashion team and oversees all day-to-day editorial content and large tentpole moments. This includes all of the runway, trend, and shopping-driven content that ultimately helps to build a strong brand reputation within the industry. Lauren's role also includes helping to set the fashion direction for all original photo shoots and often styles many of the celebrity cover shoots, including big names like Sydney Sweeney, Lindsay Lohan, and Megan Fox. 

She has also attended multiple fashion weeks, including New York, London, and Milan, where her personal style has been featured on sites such as,, and She prides herself on discovering and supporting small brands and on her knack for a good vintage shopping find. When she isn't working, she enjoys researching and dining at reputable restaurants around both her neighborhood and the globe.